Trump admin seeks health-care price transparency

Trump admin seeks health-care price transparency

Taxpayer advocates are applauding the Trump administration over its efforts calling for medical price transparency in federal employee health-care plans while health-care industry leaders are pushing back.

The Office of Personnel Management requested comments from industry leaders and health-care experts on transparency within claims data for federal employee health insurance plans.

Trent England, executive director of Save Our States, said the issue is significant for taxpayers because they pay for federal employees health-care benefits. He said the system is opaque and does not provide appropriate access to the most competitive prices in the market.

“Hospitals and other medical providers set their prices, and they benefit from the opacity,” England told The Center Square. “They benefit from the fact that it’s just hard to see.”

England said that open access to claims data could mean the difference between paying $20,000 or $12,000 for the same procedure.

The Trump administration’s pursuit of claims data from insurance companies could have an impact on private health-care insurers as well, England pointed out. He said hospitals across the country are starting to provide upfront cost assessments more often.

“We have to be able to ask the questions about why some things cost so much and other things cost so little,” England said.

Andrew Bremberg, former director of the Domestic Policy Council in the first Trump administration, applauded OPM’s efforts to pursue price transparency for federal worker insurance plans.

“It’s vital that OPM get this claims data so they can detect fraud and fight back against it,” Bremberg told The Center Square.

He said the work in health-care price transparency has been ongoing since the first Trump administration. Bremberg pointed to a recent settlement from Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey.

The insurance provider agreed to pay $100 million in November to resolve claims that it overcharged the plan in order to secure a contract to manage New Jersey’s public employee health plans.

“The health plan was paying out claims using taxpayers’ money, not their money,” Bremberg said. “The taxpayers’ money was paying out claims at a higher amount than what the provider had even billed.”

The insurance company submitted more than 1,000 false claims to the state and used fraudulent records to support them, according to New Jersey prosecutors. Horizon received nearly $500 million across five years under its contract with New Jersey due to misrepresenting claims data and charging higher amounts than it was allowed.

Increasingly, third-party pay systems have become common in health care. These entities manage daily responsibilities for self-insured employer health plans. However, England said these health-care models lead to less transparency in the market.

“Politicians have conned people into thinking health care is too important to be left to the market, and it’s just the opposite,” England said. “Health care is too important to be left to politicians.”

Industry leaders have pushed back against the Trump administration’s pursuit of claims data. Several leaders have argued that widespread publication of claims data could violate patient privacy.

England acknowledged concerns about privacy but pointed out that the federal government is entrusted with large amounts of data already. He urged individuals concerned about data sharing to trust the government.

“They don’t want these questions being asked because it gets very awkward for some of these health-care providers that charge far more than the average prices for some of these procedures,” England said.

While OPM’s actions are strictly targeted to Federal Employees Health Benefits and Postal Service Health Benefits, England said they could have a ripple effect on the private health-care industry.

“This kind of data-driven accountability should be the standard across both public and private health systems and is critical to making evidence-based reforms,” Bremberg said. “We can and must protect patient privacy, but rejecting access to claims data outright would undermine one of the most effective tools available to improve affordability and system integrity.”

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Iran economic fallout is temporary, Hassett says

Iran economic fallout is temporary, Hassett says

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square The economic fallout of the U.S. conflict in Iran will be temporary, National Economic Council Director Kevin Hassett said on Wednesday. Hassett touted the Trump...
Illinois Quick Hits: NFIB says biz deduction will bring jobs, benefit to Illinois

Illinois Quick Hits: NFIB says biz deduction will bring jobs, benefit to Illinois

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – The National Federation of Independent Business says Illinois is projected to gain 48,000 new jobs each year...
Soaring costs and short supply shut millennials out of housing market

Soaring costs and short supply shut millennials out of housing market

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square Baby Boomers continue to dominate the U.S. housing market, buying and selling more homes last year than any other generation, while homeownership remains out of...
Vought testifies before lawmakers on Trump's $2.1T budget request

Vought testifies before lawmakers on Trump’s $2.1T budget request

By Thérèse BoudreauxThe Center Square Office of Management and Budget Director Russ Vought met with U.S. lawmakers Wednesday to discuss the president’s $2.1 trillion budget proposal for the next fiscal...
SNAP eligibility changes spark debate on gap for impacted recipients

SNAP eligibility changes spark debate on gap for impacted recipients

By Sean Reed | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – A coalition of non-profits and community organizations across the state are warning that more than 200,000 Illinoisans...
Trump puts spotlight on China, Iran's top oil consumer

Trump puts spotlight on China, Iran’s top oil consumer

By Sarah Roderick-FitchThe Center Square With the blockade of Iranian ports moving toward its third day, China, Iran’s largest importer of oil, is vowing not to send weapons to the...
Lawmakers, auditors offer fraud prevention solutions

Lawmakers, auditors offer fraud prevention solutions

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square Lawmakers and auditors called on the federal government to implement legislation preventing fraud in programs run by the state. The U.S. House Oversight Subcommittee on...
Illinois unions seek to kill Waymo-friendly bill in Springfield

Illinois unions seek to kill Waymo-friendly bill in Springfield

By Sean Reed | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Leadership and rank-and-file from multiple labor unions called on lawmakers to kill legislation aimed at welcoming autonomous...
Rich States Poor States: Tax policy largely determines states’ economic competitiveness

Rich States Poor States: Tax policy largely determines states’ economic competitiveness

By Morgan SweeneyThe Center Square No matter what a state offers in terms of natural beauty, work and social opportunities, tax and economic policy — as unglamorous as they sound...
78 pro-life orgs ask DOJ to stop undermining state laws by favoring aborting drug industry

78 pro-life orgs ask DOJ to stop undermining state laws by favoring aborting drug industry

By Tate MillerThe Center Square Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America led 77 of its pro-life organization colleagues in sending the acting U.S. attorney general a letter asking the Department of...
Illinois Quick Hits: Two of ComEd four released; new trial expected

Illinois Quick Hits: Two of ComEd four released; new trial expected

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – A U.S. appellate court has ordered two defendants in the ComEd Four case to be released pending...
SB_ Litchfield vs Carlinville 04.14_5977

Gibson’s 19-Strikeout Masterpiece Lifts Carlinville Past Litchfield 2-0

Senior Hallie Gibson delivered an awe-inspiring performance in the circle, striking out a staggering 19 batters to lead the Carlinville varsity softball team to a 2-0 conference victory over host...
Chicago suit vs oil cos. may yet survive SCOTUS ruling, judge hints

Chicago suit vs oil cos. may yet survive SCOTUS ruling, judge hints

By Jonathan Bilyk | Legal NewslineThe Center Square Even as the Supreme Court considers a Colorado case that oil companies believe will decide if city and state governments can sue...
Two of ComEd Four released. new trial pending

Two of ComEd Four released. new trial pending

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – A U.S. appellate court has ordered two defendants in the ComEd Four case to be released pending...
GOP candidate Bailey urges Trump to apologize to pope; bishop calls for dialogue

GOP candidate Bailey urges Trump to apologize to pope; bishop calls for dialogue

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – After President Donald Trump refused to apologize for his social media criticism of Pope Leo XIV, a...