Bonta’s anti-Exxon emails may have run afoul of CA corruption law: Claim

Bonta’s anti-Exxon emails may have run afoul of CA corruption law: Claim

A Texas federal judge’s decision to allow ExxonMobil’s defamation lawsuit against California Attorney General Rob Bonta to move forward could ensnare Bonta in violations of state anti-corruption laws, the head of an educational nonprofit argues.

Michael J. Truncale of the Eastern District of Texas handed down a decision in February that dismissed ExxonMobil’s claims of defamation against four U.S. environmental groups and an Australian group called Intergenerational Environment Justice Fund (IEJF) that is a critic of plastics recycling. The defamation claims involved statements criticizing ExxonMobil’s advanced recycling program.

Truncale concluded the Texas court did not have personal jurisdiction over those five defendants but that it does have jurisdiction over statements made by Bonta, who in 2024 filed a lawsuit against ExxonMobil alleging the energy giant has been deceiving Californians for decades about the industry’s ability to recycle plastics.

The environmental groups that ExxonMobil accused of defamation were the Sierra Club, Surfrider Foundation, Heal the Bay and Baykeeper Inc. An attorney for the Sierra Club confirmed that the environmental groups’ motions to dismiss have been granted.

“The Sierra Club was gratified about that outcome,” attorney Scott Grant, a partner with Washington-based Boies Schiller Flexner LLP, told the Southern California Record.

In an opinion article published this month in the San Bernardino Sun, California Policy Center CEO Will Swaim argues that the court’s ruling not only makes Bonta vulnerable to a defamation verdict but offers a finding that puts the attorney general in the crosshairs of California’s anti-corruption laws.

In his opinion, Truncale quoted from statements Bonta had made about the lawsuit in an apparent fundraising email to Texas residents. The email said in part, “ExxonMobil, the largest promoter and producer of polymers used to create single-use plastics that become waste in California, spent years convincing the public that recycling makes plastic, including single-use plastic, sustainable. It doesn’t.”

The attorney general went on to say that “only 5% of U.S. plastic waste is recycled” and that the rest ends up endangering waterways, oceans, wildlife and human health, adding that ExxonMobil knew about this and lied about it.

Truncale rejected Bonta’s argument that the defamation case against him should be dismissed because the statements were made in the course of his official duties.

“Bonta believes his email was official communication that just so happened to include a campaign contribution link,” the judge said in his opinion. “It is the link’s presence that changes things. Here, the contribution request betrays the email’s true nature: a campaign promotion. Campaigning is not within Bonta’s scope of employment.”

Swaim’s opinion piece indicates that at least two California Department of Justice attorneys helped to defend Bonta in the Texas case, adding that several California statutes bar an official’s use of public office for political fundraising.

“The judge’s decision that Bonta made the statements in his personal – rather than purely professional – capacity opens a legal challenge for Bonta back home,” he said.

But Swaim acknowledged that the likelihood Bonta will be held accountable for violations of anti-corruption laws is remote, given that state judges and the California Fair Political Practices Commission administrators are appointed by Democratic Party members and are less likely to initiate prosecutions against statewide Democratic officeholders such as Bonta.

The state Attorney General’s Office did not respond to a request for comment about the defamation lawsuit.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Litchfield Logo Graphic.3

Litchfield Council Rejects One-Way Street Proposal for Post Office

City of Litchfield Meeting | January 6, 2026 Article Summary: The Litchfield City Council voted down a proposal to convert Kirkham Street into a one-way thoroughfare, a change requested by...
Foreign national charged with having gun near ICE agents in Chicago

Foreign national charged with having gun near ICE agents in Chicago

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – A Mexican national has been charged with illegally possessing and firing a loaded handgun in Chicago near...
Tariffs sink Canadian couples' long-running e-commerce operation

Tariffs sink Canadian couples’ long-running e-commerce operation

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square Lana Bain and her husband had been selling antiques online for nearly 30 years when the U.S. tariffs hit. At first it was higher prices...
Attorneys file request to Supreme Court over gender secrecy

Attorneys file request to Supreme Court over gender secrecy

By Esther WickhamThe Center Square The Thomas More Society has filed an emergency application with the U.S. Supreme Court, requesting intervention in the Mirabelli v. Bonta lawsuit over gender secrecy...
Pritzker signs energy omnibus with new charge for ratepayers in 2030

Pritzker signs energy omnibus with new charge for ratepayers in 2030

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Gov. J.B. Pritzker has signed sweeping energy legislation that will add a new line item to Illinois...
Illinois quick hits: Primary election ballot certified; indictments increased in 2025

Illinois quick hits: Primary election ballot certified; indictments increased in 2025

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square Primary election ballot certified The Illinois State Board of Elections certified the March 2026 primary ballot this week, removing several Republican...
Trump orders $200 billion mortgage bond buy to lower rates

Trump orders $200 billion mortgage bond buy to lower rates

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square President Donald Trump said Thursday afternoon that the federal government will buy $200 billion in mortgage bonds to bring down interest rates and monthly payments....
Coal and power groups back UP–Norfolk Southern rail merger

Coal and power groups back UP–Norfolk Southern rail merger

By Tom JoyceThe Center Square Several major coal producers and power industry groups are urging federal regulators to approve the proposed Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger. The producers argue that reliable...

WATCH: U.S. House votes to extend ACA subsidies, heads to Senate

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square The U.S. House of Representatives passed a bill to extend Affordable Care Act subsidies for another three years. The bill passed in a 230-196 vote...
Report details sexual abuse, falsified grant applications at Chicago Public Schools

Report details sexual abuse, falsified grant applications at Chicago Public Schools

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – The Chicago Board of Education’s Office of Inspector General has released a report detailing falsified federal grant...
Signature shortfalls knock multiple candidates off Illinois ballot

Signature shortfalls knock multiple candidates off Illinois ballot

By Catrina Barker | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – The Illinois State Board of Elections certified the March 2026 primary ballot this week, removing several...

WATCH: Vance addresses Minneapolis shooting, questions leftwing influence

By Sarah Roderick-FitchThe Center Square Vice President JD Vance on Thursday questioned potential leftwing involvement in the shooting death of a woman by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer in...
U.S. House clears $180B funding bills to avoid Jan. 30 shutdown

U.S. House clears $180B funding bills to avoid Jan. 30 shutdown

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square The U.S. House of Representatives on Thursday cleared three nearly $180 billion government funding bills that will take a step toward preventing a federal government...
IL state lawmaker pushes back as analysis finds municipalities lost $10.9B

IL state lawmaker pushes back as analysis finds municipalities lost $10.9B

By Catrina Barker | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – A new Illinois Policy Institute analysis estimates local governments have lost $10.9 billion since 2012 due...
Trump invites Colombian president to White House

Trump invites Colombian president to White House

By Sarah Roderick-FitchThe Center Square In a matter of days, President Donald Trump has gone from threatening to strike Colombia to inviting its leader to the White House. Following a...